These scams pick up every year in November and December. In my experience, the reasons have nothing to do with technology.
People are busier. There are more legitimately unusual requests going around, so an unusual request stops standing out. Real packages arrive all the time, so a fake delivery notice looks like the seven real ones.
Owners and managers are traveling or out. An email in place of a conversation seems normal. And many small businesses have temporary or seasonal staff who do not yet know how things are normally done.
Email filtering alone does not solve a problem like that. Here is what to expect and what I'd put in place to stop it.
The fake delivery notice
It is a message about a package: a failed delivery, a customs charge, an address to confirm, or a tracking link. It shows up at a time of year when everyone is expecting something.
Usually it wants a login or your card details. Sometimes the link installs something instead. Look at where it asks you to act. It wants you to use its own link instead of something you already had.
The rule I'd set is to never resolve a delivery problem from the message. Go to the carrier website yourself, or use the tracking number from the order confirmation you already have.
The gift card request
This is an email that looks like it came from the owner or a manager. It is short and urgent. The sender is in a meeting and can't take a call. They need gift cards bought for a client or for staff, with the codes sent back by email or text.
It is cheap to run. It also targets helpfulness instead of carelessness. The person who falls for it is usually the one most eager to help the boss, and December gives a believable reason for the request.
My rule: gift cards are never bought because of a message, from anyone, for any reason. Make it absolute. A rule that depends on judgment breaks down under time pressure. If the owner really does need gift cards, the owner can pick up the phone.
The changed bank details
This is the most expensive one by a wide margin. It is also the least dramatic to look at.
A supplier you really do work with emails to say their bank account has changed and asks you to update it before the next payment. The message can come from the supplier's real mailbox after it has been compromised, in a real thread, with correct references and a believable reason. Or it looks like an invoice you were already expecting, arriving the same week several real ones do.
Year end makes it worse. Payment runs cluster and everyone is trying to close things out before the holidays.
My rule: bank details are never changed because of an email. Confirm by phone, using a number you already had and never one from the message. That is one phone call, every time, with no exceptions for urgency.
It is the same fraud we covered in why phishing keeps getting past your filter. I still see it as the gap we find most often in otherwise careful businesses.
The fake invoice or renewal
This is an invoice for something that sounds reasonable, like a domain renewal, a directory listing, a software subscription, or an office supply order. It is small enough to approve without much thought, especially in a month with a lot of real invoices while the person who normally checks them is away.
My rule: every invoice gets matched to something you ordered. Anything you do not recognize goes to one named person instead of getting paid because it looks routine.
The charity appeal
These are seasonal, aimed at businesses that really do give, and they work. The request arrives by email with a payment link and a deadline.
I'd decide what your business gives on its own schedule, never in response to an email that shows up. If a cause is worth supporting, go to the organization's own website and give there.
The scam aimed at seasonal staff
Temporary staff get targeted because they do not know yet what normal looks like. They don't know that the owner never emails about payments or that the finance manager never asks for a password. They also don't know who to check with when something seems off.
I would brief them on their first day. It takes two sentences: here is what we never do by email, and here is who to ask if you get something strange. Then make sure asking is welcome, because a temporary employee who is worried about looking foolish won't ask.
The two-minute conversation
Almost all of this is prevented by one short conversation at a staff meeting. I'd have it in November, before the busy weeks start, instead of in January.
Say these four things:
- Nobody here will ever ask you by email or text to buy gift cards. If you get that message, it is fake no matter whose name is on it.
- We never change a supplier's bank details from an email. We call a number we already have, every time.
- If a message pushes you to act quickly, that is your signal to slow down and check with someone.
- Nobody will ever be criticized for checking, or for reporting something they clicked on. We would much rather hear about it in the first hour.
The fourth point is the one I see left out most. It decides whether the other three hold up in a busy December. An employee who is afraid of looking foolish hides the mistake, and hidden mistakes are the ones that get expensive.
What technology does and does not cover
Email filtering removes a lot of this before anyone sees it. Multi-factor authentication (a second check, like a code on your phone, on top of the password) makes a stolen password much less useful. Both are worth having, and both are on the short list of security steps I think matter most.
Neither one stops a legitimate employee from making a legitimate payment to a criminal's bank account. That payment is what most of these scams are after. A rule about phone calls and a workplace where checking is welcome are what stop it, and both need to be in place before December. Regular security awareness training keeps those rules fresh after the season ends.
If you'd like help writing the payment rule down or planning what to tell your staff, book a free 15-minute call with me. Let me know what works best for you.